Return to Question

a) If someone is really depressed and want to commit suicide, are there any punishments for this also in garuda-purana?

b) Doesn't it means that they have more pain than they could bear so it's not entirely their fault to commit suicide. (Assuming these pains are so severe that no one in that person's place could bear it, and without support and encouragement)

c) We have pain and bad incidents according to our deeds (karma) in this life and from past lives, so don't you think all these should be in a particular limit (more punishment than that shifted to next life?) so that no one committed suicide, and was able to bear their punishments.

Edit: I read a story in which the person steals some food and then since his intention was good, INDRA himself came to take him to Swarg.
So I think reasons should also be seen for anything we do, since there are reasons for everything we do.

a) If someone is really depressed and want to commit suicide, are there any punishments for this also in garuda-purana?

b) Doesn't it means that they have more pain than they could bear so it's not entirely their fault to commit suicide. (Assuming these pains are so severe that no one in that person's place could bear it, and without support and encouragement)

c) We have pain and bad incidents according to our deeds (karma) in this life and from past lives, so don't you think all these should be in a particular limit (more punishment than that shifted to next life?) so that no one commits suicide, and be able to bear their punishments.

Edit: I read a story in which the person steals some food and give to a poor family with which he has no relation then since his intention was good, INDRA himself came to take him to Swarg.
So I think reasons should also be seen for any punishments , since there are reasons for everything we do.

a) If someone is really depressed and want to suicide. Are there any punishment for this also in garuda-purana?

b) Doesn't it means that he has pain more then he could bear so it's not entirely his fault to do suicide. (These pains are too much that no one on that person's place can bear it and without support and no encouragement)

C) We have pain and bad incidents according to our dids (karma) in this life and from past life, don't you think all these should be in a particular limit (more punishment than that shifted to next life?) so that no one suicide and be able to bear his punishments.

Edit: I read a story in which the person steals some food and then since his intention was good so INDRA himself came to take him to Swarg. So I think reasons should also be seen for anything you do,since there are reasons for everything we do.

a) If someone is really depressed and want to commit suicide, are there any punishments for this also in garuda-purana?

b) Doesn't it means that they have more pain than they could bear so it's not entirely their fault to commit suicide. (Assuming these pains are so severe that no one in that person's place could bear it, and without support and encouragement)

c) We have pain and bad incidents according to our deeds (karma) in this life and from past lives, so don't you think all these should be in a particular limit (more punishment than that shifted to next life?) so that no one committed suicide, and was able to bear their punishments.

Edit: I read a story in which the person steals some food and then since his intention was good, INDRA himself came to take him to Swarg. 
So I think reasons should also be seen for anything we do, since there are reasons for everything we do.

a) If someone is really depressed and want to suicide  . Are there any punishment for this also in garuda-purana?

b) Doesn't it means that he has pain more then he could bear so it's not entirely his fault to do suicide. (Sometimes to get irritated and quarrel and fight because of situations and anyone would do same thing)

C) We have pain and bad incidents according to our dids (karma) in this life and from past life, don't you think all these should be in a particular limit (more than that for next life?) so that no one suicide and be able to bear his punishments.

Edit: I read a story in which the person steals some food and then since his intention was good so INDRA himself came to take him to Swarg. So I think reasons should also be seen for anything you do,since there are reasons for everything we do.

a) If someone is really depressed and want to suicide. Are there any punishment for this also in garuda-purana?

b) Doesn't it means that he has pain more then he could bear so it's not entirely his fault to do suicide. (These pains are too much that no one on that person's place can bear it and without support and no encouragement)

C) We have pain and bad incidents according to our dids (karma) in this life and from past life, don't you think all these should be in a particular limit (more punishment than that shifted to next life?) so that no one suicide and be able to bear his punishments.

Edit: I read a story in which the person steals some food and then since his intention was good so INDRA himself came to take him to Swarg. So I think reasons should also be seen for anything you do,since there are reasons for everything we do.