1

Bhagavad Gita 9.29

I am equally disposed to all living beings; I am neither inimical nor partial to anyone. But the devotees who worship Me with love reside in Me and I reside in them.

Bhagavad Gita 9.30

Even if the vilest sinners worship Me with exclusive devotion, they are to be considered righteous because they have made the proper resolve.

My question is how does God remain equal and non partial to all when he forgives vilest of all sinners?

an example : Person X looted hard earned money from houses of hard working people. Then after ,few years Person X realizes all this is just an illusion of Maya and surrender all his upcoming actions to Shri Krishna .Now ,he will burn all past karmas as mentioned in

Bhagavad Gita 4.37 As a kindled fire reduces wood to ashes, O Arjun, so does the fire of knowledge burn to ashes all reactions from material activities.

So, in this case would not it be unjust for the poor people who worked hard to earn money. Would this case violate the principle that God is equal and just towards all (mentioned in chapter 9 verse 29)

[please use commentaries of acharyas before giving personal opinions]

1 Answer 1

1

Let's look at the verse 9.30:

अपि चेत्सुदुराचारो भजते मामनन्यभाक् ।
साधुरेव स मन्तव्य: सम्यग्व्यवसितो हि स: ॥ ३० ॥

Even if one commits the most abominable action, if he is engaged in devotional service he is to be considered saintly because he is properly situated in his determination.

Through the words अपि चेत्सुदुराचारो and साधुरेव स मन्तव्य: Krishna cautions against judging a devotee's accidental falldowns due to his inability to give them up initially during sadhana.

Commentary by Swami Prabhupada: They are a warning to the nondevotees that because of an accidental falldown a devotee should not be derided; he should still be considered saintly even if he has accidentally fallen down. And the word mantavyaḥ is still more emphatic. If one does not follow this rule, and derides a devotee for his accidental falldown, then one is disobeying the order of the Supreme Lord. The only qualification of a devotee is to be unflinchingly and exclusively engaged in devotional service.

In the Nṛsimha Purāṇa the following statement is given:

bhagavati ca harāv ananya-cetā bhṛśa-malino ’pi virājate manuṣyaḥ na hi śaśa-kaluṣa-cchabiḥ kadācit timira-parābhavatām upaiti candraḥ

The meaning is that even if one fully engaged in the devotional service of the Lord is sometimes found engaged in abominable activities, these activities should be considered to be like the spots that resemble the mark of a rabbit on the moon. Such spots do not become an impediment to the diffusion of moonlight. Similarly, the accidental falldown of a devotee from the path of saintly character does not make him abominable.

Commentary by Sri Vishvanatha Chakravarti Thakur:

My attachment to my devotee is my very nature. That attachment does not decrease even if the devotee commits wrong, for I make him come up to the highest standard. If someone with bad conduct, addicted to violence, thievery, or adultery (suduracarah), worships me, and worships no one except me, and does not follow any other process like karma or jnana, and has no other desire than my desire (ananya bhak), he is my devotee (sadhuh).

“But, considering his bad conduct, how is he a devotee?”

“He is to be respected (mantavyah) as a devotee because of his devotee qualities. It is a command. Not doing so is offense. My order is the authority.”

“So he should be considered a devotee in that portion where he worship You, and as a non-devotee in that portion where he commits adultery?”

“No, he should be considered as a devotee (eva) in all his parts. You should not see his bad qualities at all. He is completely convinced (samyak vyavasitah). He makes a splendid resolution: ‘I will go to hell for my sinful actions which are hard to give up, but I will not give up dedicated worship of Krishna.'”

Let's look at the subsequent verse 9.31 to understand this further.

क्षिप्रं भवति धर्मात्मा शश्वच्छान्तिं निगच्छति । कौन्तेय प्रतिजानीहि न मे भक्त: प्रणश्यति ॥ ३१ ॥

He quickly becomes righteous and attains lasting peace. O son of Kuntī, declare it boldly that My devotee never perishes.

Krishna uses the words क्षिप्रं भवति धर्मात्मा which mean that the Bhakta will become a Dharmatma or an elevated personality very quickly. He wouldn't have said so if he were a deliberate offender.

Commentary by Sri Vishvanatha Chakravarti Thakur:

"How can you accept the worship of such a sinful person? How can you eat the food and drink offered by a heart contaminated with lust and anger?”

“Very quickly he becomes righteous.” The present is used and not the future to express the fact that having committed sin, by remembering me, he becomes repentant, and very quickly becomes righteous. “O how unfortunate I am! There is no one as low as I, bringing bad name to the devotees.” Repeatedly (sasvat), he feels completely (ni) disgust (santim).

In short, the Lord is equal to all in granting justice but shows special favor to those who after dedicating their lives in His service accidentally commit some sin and repeatedly repent in their hearts.

Link for commentaries on these verses by various Acharyas to understand them further.

2
  • In Commentary by Sri Vishvanatha Chakravarti Thakur," He makes a splendid resolution: ‘I will go to hell for my sinful actions which are hard to give up, but I will not give up dedicated worship of Krishna.'” Why should make such a resolution like this when all his material activities would be burned like fire reduces wood to ashes
    – user40980
    Commented Aug 28 at 5:40
  • It isn't black & white. Please read the previous verses with the commentaries. The extent to which the devotee progresses in their remembrance of Krishna, to that extent the material activities reduce (which are now in a seed form). However, these do not discount his position as a bhakta in the eyes of Krishna.
    – Harihara
    Commented Aug 28 at 13:28

You must log in to answer this question.