6

Bharata told to Rama and Lakshmana that King Dasaratha died. Immediately, Rama tells Lakshmana that your father is dead. But Rama is also a son of Dasaratha.

What is the reason behind Rama telling Lakshmana that your father is dead? Why didn't he say 'our father has died' or just 'father has died?'

  • 1
    I think Periyavachan Pillai talks about this in his Tanishloki. – Surya Oct 5 '16 at 7:39
  • @Mani--It is in valmiki Ramayan only. I have read in the book Vedaraman. Will give the chapter number tomorrow. – Parthasarathy Raghavan Oct 5 '16 at 8:55
  • @Surya---May be but I read in Vedaraman book. – Parthasarathy Raghavan Oct 5 '16 at 8:55
  • When God Sri Rama, "himself", says something, there does not exist any room for speculations.When wise people, across the world, donot speculate on the word of God through the Sages, which is called as Vedas, God Sri Rama’s words, also - donot leave any room for speculation. – Uday Krishna Oct 23 '16 at 17:24
10

In the Valmiki Ramayana, Ayodhya Kanda, Sarga 103, Sloka 15, Rama says पित्रा हीनोऽसि लक्ष्मण meaning "O Lakshmana, You became fatherless."

Following explanation is based on Brahmasri Chaganti Koteswara Rao's speech on Ramayana.

If father dies, elder brother is considered to be equivalent to or taking the position of father. Since Dasaratha died Rama has to treat Lakshmana as a father. Though the exile is only for Rama, Lakshmana came along with him to forest (even though not necessary) and Lakshmana is doing service to Rama. So Rama is not able to be a good father-like in caring about Lakshmana. But instead Lakshmana is serving Rama and taking care of him like a father.

Rama is seeing a father in Lakshmana even though Dasaratha died. So that is why Rama said to Lakshmana "you became fatherless."

  • @SwiftPushkar See my answer given below for the scriptural source u are looking for. – Rickross Oct 23 '16 at 5:19
4

The answer given by @Student is correct.

However, let me add in this answer, the Scriptural verses which says that an elder brother is equivalent to the father when the later dies.It will also answer the following question raised by @SwiftPushkar:

You have mentioned this "If father dies, elder brother is considered to be equivalent to or taking the position of father." Which Hinduism scripture states this law?

Source-Manu Smriti, Chapter 9.

Context-Deciding the shares of parental property after death of the father .

9.108. As a father (supports) his sons, so let the eldest support his younger brothers, and let them also in accordance with the law behave towards their eldest brother as sons (behave towards their father).

9.110. If the eldest brother behaves as an eldest brother (ought to do), he (must be treated) like a mother and like a father; but if he behaves in a manner unworthy of an eldest brother, he should yet be honoured like a kinsman.

enter image description here

Another verse(from Manu smriti) which says(indirectly) that an elder brother is like(equivalent to) a father to the younger brother is this:

9.57. The wife of an elder brother is for his younger (brother) the wife of a Guru; but the wife of the younger is declared (to be) the daughter-in-law of the elder.

enter image description here

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .