3

This question already has an answer here:

Among the 18 major Puranas one is called the Garuda Purana.Usually its recited during death rites .

There is also a belief that it should only be recited during death rites and not in normal circumstances i.e where no death has occurred in a family.

To verify the Scriptural basis of this belief i mailed one very learned(Shastragya) person( with whom i correspond quite often) who is very closely associated with the Kaamakoti.org's activities.

He has written a lot of books,on topics like Upanishads,Smritis,Puranas,Itihasas etc, which are hosted by Kamakoti.

I am giving below the correspondence that i had with him through e-mail:

Me-Dear Sir,

You have written books on every major Puranas but not any on the Garuda Purana. Does it mean that not everyone is allowed to read or hear it in normal circumstances?Are there any such prohibitions?

Expert-yes, HH Vijyendra Saraswati asked me not to translate and concise Garuda purana

So, to my question "Are there any such prohibitions?" he replied "Yes[there are] and then he said that even Sri Vijyendra Saraswati opposed the idea of making the summary of Garuda Purana publicly available on their site for everybody's perusal.(and this can verified easily by visiting their site as well which provides summaries of all Puranas except the Garuda Purana)

That proves that the belief might not be just a belief and there are indeed some concerns regarding making Garuda Purana available publicly or on it being read on normal days.

Questions

1) Are there prohibitions regarding reading or hearing Garuda Purana and if yes which Scriptures mention them?

2) Or are there some chapters in the Purana that make it unfit to be recited by everyone & on any occasions?If yes,which are those chapters?

marked as duplicate by sv., Paṇḍyā, SwiftPushkar, Mr. P, Sarvabhouma Feb 21 '17 at 8:26

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • Did you ask Kamakoti people about scriptural reference for this practice? – The Destroyer Feb 2 '17 at 11:25
  • @TheDestroyer No i did not want to bother him with more questions ..primarily becoz if i did so it wud have been like questioning the authority of Sri Vijendra Saraswati...Once Sri Saraswati has said so we must believe him..& secondarily becoz he remains very busy and he is elderly too..The work of finding the actual Scriptural reference can now be done on sites like this.. – Rickross Feb 2 '17 at 12:23
  • 1
    I don't think he would be bothered by that. He would have easily said the sources unlike us, as they are experts in the subject. – The Destroyer Feb 2 '17 at 12:45
  • @Rickross How is this question not a duplicate of other question? Both seem same to me. – sv. Feb 2 '17 at 15:58
  • There's a program called Dharma Sandhehalu in Telugu channel Bhakti TV. Many knowledgeable Pundits from Telugu states provide answers to questions. I saw opinions of 3 pundits and none of them say this is correct. One Pundit says "Puranas can be read at any time without any exceptions" (quotes Sanskrit verse written by Vyasa). – The Destroyer Feb 2 '17 at 17:00

Browse other questions tagged .