Is there a mention of World Turtle/World Elephant theory in Hindu scripture? I heard many unsourced stories about Sheshanaga or Nandi being the one holding the earth on their head/horns respectively. But I want to know from scripture point of view, who holds the earth/bhumi?
Sankaracharya says all the stories of creation are ''likely stories" to explain the existence of Maya. All the stories are from within the realm of Maya. Pick which one you like. Brahman alone is real. The Mandukya Upanishad (III.15) says: "The creation that has been multifariously set forth with the help of the examples of earth, gold, sparks, etc, is merely by way of generating the idea of (oneness); but there is no multiplicity in any way." - If there is no multiplicity, who supports whom?– Swami VishwanandaMay 29, 2017 at 9:00
I can provide scriptural reference for Adi Sesha holding earth. Do you want elephant and turtle story or Adi Sesha part?– The Destroyer ♦May 29, 2017 at 10:08
@TheDestroyer all of them– Ankit SharmaMay 29, 2017 at 10:09
@SwiftPushkar I heard that one too but I am looking for scriptures only ( vedas, purana etc)– Ankit SharmaMay 29, 2017 at 10:22
@AnkitSharma I've never heard of Nandi holding the Earth. But Muslims believe that the Earth is supported on the horns of a bull.– Keshav Srinivasan ♦May 29, 2017 at 16:44
Here are scriptural sources that describe different kinds of animals supporting the Earth:
World Elephants: In the Bala Kanda of the Ramayana, Indra steals the horse of Ashwamedha Yagna of Rama's ancestor Sagara, and so Sagara tells his sons to dig the Earth to find the horse, as described in this chapter of the Bala Kanda of the Ramayana:
"Let the earth be dug further, may safety be with you, and verily splitting open the surface of the earth you catch hold of the thief of the horse, and on achieving your purpose you may return to me." In this way Sagara ordered his sons. On catching up the words of their father, the great-souled Sagara, his sixty thousand sons rushed towards the surface of the rasaa tala, the netherworld. While digging the earth there they beheld a mountain similar easterly elephant named Viruupaaksha, which is bearing the eastern side of earth's surface on its head. Oh, Rama, the legatee of Raghu, that great easterly elephant Viruupaaksha is bearing the entire eastern earth along with its mountains and forests on its head. They circumambulated the great elephant in supplication, oh Rama, and on worshipping that elephant which is the protector of easterly direction they proceeded to netherworld duly splitting the earth. After splitting the eastern direction then they split opened the southern direction, and even in southern direction they beheld an elephant that is similar to a very great mountain, and that is sustaining southerly side of earth on its head, and on seeing that mammoth elephant of venerable character, namely Mahapadma, they went into an inordinate astonishment. On circumabulating that elephant Mahaapada in supplication, they the sixty thousand sons of great-souled Sagara scooped out the westerly direction. Even in the westerly direction those great mighty sons of Sagara beheld an infinite and mountain similar elephant of western direction, called Sumanasa. Circumabulating that elephant namely Sumanasa in western side, and even on asking about its well-being, then they reached the northern direction duly digging the earth. In the northern direction, oh, Rama, they beheld Bhadra, a snow-white elephant with an auspicious body bearing northern side of this earth. On touching that elephant reverently and also circumambulating it, those sixty thousands sons of Sagara further burrowed to the surface of the earth. The sons of Sagara have then gone to the auspicious northeast direction, iishaana digbhaaga, Shiva sthaana, and all those sons of Sagara have tunnelled the earth rancorously. The eyes of the princes are agitated in fury in construing the sage Kapila as the stealer of ritual-horse, and they furiously dashed towards him wielding crowbars, ploughs, and various trees and boulders, and shouting at him, 'stay, stay.'
Kapila burnt the sons of Sagara to ashes, which necessitated the famous story of the descent of the Ganga. But what's relevant for our purposes is that the Earth is described as being supported by four World Elephants: Virupaksha who supports the Eastern quarter, Mahapadma who supports the Southern quarter, Sumanasa who supports the Western quarter, and Bhadra who supports the North quarter. Also, the next chapter of the Bala Kanda of the Ramayana describes these four elephants as eloquent and revered by the gods and other beings:
And he that resplendent Amshuman beheld one of the four directional elephant of the earth which is being venerated by gods, monsters, demons, imps, vultures and serpents.... All the elephants that safeguard the directions of earth which have the faculties of articulation and eloquence have adored Amshuman and motivated him by saying, 'you will be going from here taking the horse.'
In any case, the four World Elephants are also described in this chapter of the Srimad Bhagavatam, albeit with different names:
On the top of Lokāloka Mountain are the four gaja-patis, the best of elephants, which were established in the four directions by Lord Brahmā, the supreme spiritual master of the entire universe. The names of those elephants are Ṛṣabha, Puṣkaracūḍa, Vāmana and Aparājita. They are responsible for maintaining the planetary systems of the universe.
World Tortoise: The 8th century Hindu astronomer Lalla mentions it as one of the Puranic theories he is trying to refute in this chapter of his Shishyavriddhida Tantra:
Some say that the earth is supported by a tortoise, a serpent, a boar, an elephant, or by mountain ranges.... If the earth is supported by tortoise and other things, by whom are they supported in space? If these can reman in space (unsupported), what prevents the earth from remaining thus (i.e. unsupported)?
And it's described in this chapter of the Devi Bhagavatam:
By Whose command the wind supports the water; the water supports the tortoise; the tortoise supports the Ananta and the Ananta supports the earth; the earth supports the oceans, mountain and all the jewels.
But I don't know anywhere else in Hindu scripture where this notion is mentioned.
World Serpent: This is the most common theory found in Hindu scripture. Here's how this chapter of the Vishnu Purana describes it:
The extent of the surface of the earth has been thus described to you, Maitreya. Its depth below the surface is said to be seventy thousand Yojanas, each of the seven regions of Pátála extending downwards ten thousand. These seven, worthy Muni, are called Atala, Vitala, Nitala, Gabhastimat, Mahátala, Sutala, and Pátála.... Below the seven Pátálas is the form of Vishńu, proceeding from the quality of darkness, which is called Śesha, the excellencies of which neither Daityas nor Dánavas can fully enumerate.... Śesha bears the entire world, like a diadem, upon his head, and he is the foundation on which the seven Pátálas rest. His power, his glory, his form, his nature, cannot be described, cannot he comprehended by the gods themselves. Who shall recount his might, who wears this whole earth, like a garland of flowers, tinged of a purple dye by the radiance of the jewels of his crests.
This chapter of the Adi Parva of the Mahabharata describes how Adiseshan became the supporter of the Earth. It was a duty given to him by Brahma as a result of his Tapasya:
Then Sesha replied, 'O divine Grandsire, this is the boon desired by me; viz., may my heart always delight in virtue and in blessed ascetic penances, O Lord of all!' Brahman said, 'O Sesha, I am exceedingly gratified with this thy self-denial and love of peace. But, at my command, let this act be done by thee for the good of my creatures. Bear thou, O Sesha, properly and well this Earth so unsteady with her mountains and forests, her seas and towns and retreats, so that she may be steady.' Sesha said, 'O divine Lord of all creatures, O bestower of boons, O lord of the Earth, lord of every created thing, lord of the universe, I will, even as thou sayest hold the Earth steady. Therefore, O lord of all creatures, place her on my head.' Brahman said, 'O best of snakes, go underneath the Earth. She will herself give thee a crevice to pass through. And, O Sesha, by holding the Earth, thou shalt certainly do what is prized by me very greatly.' ... Then the elder brother of the king of the snakes, entering a hole, passed to the other side of the Earth, and holding her, supported with his head that goddess with her belt of seas passing all round.' Brahman said, 'O Sesha, O best of snakes, thou art the god Dharma, because alone, with thy huge body, thou supportest the Earth with everything on her, even as I myself, or Valavit (Indra), can.' ... The snake, Sesha, the lord Ananta, of great prowess, lives underneath the Earth, alone supporting the world at the command of Brahman. And the illustrious Grandsire, the best of the immortals, then gave unto Ananta the bird of fair feathers, viz., the son of Vinata, for Ananta's help.'"
I'm not sure how Vishnu's bird Garuda helps Vishnu's serpent Adiseshan support the Earth though. In any case, here's how this chapter of the Srimad Bhaagavatam describes Adiseshan supporting the Earth:
My dear King, approximately 240,000 miles beneath the planet Pātāla lives another incarnation of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. He is the expansion of Lord Viṣṇu known as Lord Ananta or Lord Saṅkarṣaṇa.... This great universe, situated on one of Lord Anantadeva’s thousands of hoods, appears just like a white mustard seed. It is infinitesimal compared to the hood of Lord Ananta.
So as you can see, there's many different world animal theories, and sometimes these animals are described as stacked on top of each other. In any case, some people (like ISKCON members for instance) reconcile these theories with our understanding of the world by saying that the Earth is just Jambudvipa or even just Bharatavarsha, and that it is some much larger entity, like the entire physical Universe, which is the Bhuloka carried by Adiseshan.
But I want to know form scripture point of view, who holds the earth/bhumi?
Chapter 15 of Umasamhita of Shiva Purana says Adi Sesha holds the Earth.
तस्याधारः स्थितो नागः स च विष्णुः प्रकीर्तितः।
ब्रह्मणो वचसो हेतोबिभर्तिं सकलं त्विदम्।।११।।
Sesa is the base of the globe, who is also called Visnu, who according to Brahma preserves the universe.
अास्ते पातालमूलस्थः सशेषः क्षितिमण्डलम्।
बिभ्रत्स्वपृष्ठे भूतेशः शेषोऽशेषगुणार्चितः।।१८।।
He is lodged at the base of Patala and is adored with innumerable virtues. He is lord of all the living beings. Such a type of serpent Sesa carries the earth (Kshiti Mandala) over his back.
तस्य वीर्यप्रभावश्च साकांक्षैस्त्रिदशैरपि।
न हि वर्णयितुं शक्यः स्वरूपं ज्ञातुमेव वा।।१९।।
The gods are unable to describe his prowess, though they are desirous to do so. His real form also cannot be known.
आस्ते कुसुममालेव फणामणिशिलारुणा।
यस्यैषा सकला पृथ्वी कस्तद्वार्यं वदिष्यति।।२०।।
The earth is lodged over his hoods with red complexion, like the garland. Therefore who can describe his strength?
यदा विजृम्भतेऽनन्तो मदाघूर्णितलोचनः।
तदा चलति भूरेषा साद्रितोयाधिकानना।२१।
Getting intoxicated when he rolls his eyes, yawning at the same time then the earth with mountains, oceans and forests, shakes.
Srimad Bhagavatam 5.25.2 also says the same.
यस्येदं क्षिति-मण्डलं भगवतो ’नन्त-मूर्तेः सहस्र-शिरस एकस्मिन्न् एव शीर्षणि ध्रियमाणं सिद्धार्थ इव लक्ष्यते||
Śukadeva Gosvāmī continued: This great universe (ksiti mandalam), situated on one of Lord Anantadeva’s thousands of hoods, appears just like a white mustard seed. It is infinitesimal compared to the hood of Lord Ananta.
Though Srila Prabhupada translates "kShiti maNDala" as Universe, dictionaries say kShiti maNDala is Earth.
Yes Kshiti is prithvi.. From the bottom the last tattva among the 36 tattvas is called prithvi or kshiti tattva. May 29, 2017 at 15:52
@Rickross But doesn't Kshiti tatwa refer to every solid tatwa?.. ie. Solidness of Moon and Other things are also Kshiti tatwa... isn't it?...– TezzMay 29, 2017 at 15:58
@Tezz Kshiti means Prithvi that much know. May 29, 2017 at 16:47
There must some Puranic stories saying something or the other. But in Vedas its clearly stated that its truth that upholds or supports the earth.
So I am only answering the following question of yours.
But I want to know form scripture point of view, who holds the earth/bhumi?
satyena uttabhita bhumihi.
The earth is supported by the truth.
Atharva Veda 14.1.1
Here is another relevant Veda mantra :
Satyam brihat ritham ugram , dikshA tapo brahma yajna , prithvim dhArayanthi.
The truth, the vast, truth-in-movement (ritam), strength (ugram), consecration (dikshA), tapas (askesis), mantra (brahma) and yajna. These uphold the Earth.
Atharva Veda 12.1.1
1Please provide an answer for the question first. Nov 23, 2019 at 16:56
@HarshitGangwar I have answered the Q. It's called "partially answering" the Q. Nov 24, 2019 at 14:16
Apart from the puranas the theory of earth being supported or upholded by four elephents is mentioned in "Brihatsamhita" by Varaha-Mihira". Chapter 32 " Bhukampa Laxan Adhyay , Signs of an earthquake.
क्षितिकंम्पमाहुरेके बृहदन्तर्जलनिवासिसत्वकृतम् ।
भूभारखिन्नदिग्गजविश्रामसमुद्भवं चान्ये ॥१॥
Some hold that an earth-quake is caused by huge animals living in the midst of the ocean , while others opine that it is the result of the rest that is availed of by the elephants of the quarters tired by the weight of the earth.
Now what Varaha-Mihira says in this shloka is that ,earth-quakes are caused by tried elephents who are upholding or supporting the earth.And ultimately that the earth is supported by four elephents.
You can read here more about Varaha-mihira
It should be noted that Varahamira rejects this explanation and ultimately supports the theory that earthquakes are caused by the Vayu-circle, the Agni-circle, the Indra-circle, and the Varuna-circle. May 29, 2017 at 14:09
As per the Skanda Mahā-Purāṇa:
the Earth rest on the four cosmic-elephants,
the Elephants stand on the cosmic-tortoise,
the tortoise is further supported by the Adi-Shesha: Ananta,
The combination of elephants, tortoise and serpent Ananta are all supported by the unmanifest energies of God Vishnu himself.
This description is found in the excerpt from the Skanda Purāṇa, after Vishnu lifts the Earth from the cosmic water and places her on a supported axis, as discussed above.
Chapter 36, Veṅkaṭācala-māhātmya, Vaiṣṇava-khaṇḍa, Skanda-purāṇa
Rishi Bharadvāja said:
20-26. After lifting up the Earth from beneath the nether worlds thus the Lord placed her firmly in the midst of the waters of the Ocean.
When the Earth was lifted up by him, the water that filled up the space between the Earth and the atmosphere became the inviolable line of demarcation of the boundary made by him.
After establishing the Earth thus he placed the Elephants of the Quarters, the King of Serpents and the Tortoise for giving her extra support. That receptacle of mercy (Hari) willingly applied his own Śakti (power) in an unmanifest form as a support for them all.
As Hari thus stood in the form of Boar after retrieving the Earth, the residents of Janaloka beginning with Sanaka eulogized him.
After propitiating Puruṣottama in the form of Boar and at his behest, Brahmā created the universe as before.
Thus, as per the Skanda Mahā-Purāṇa, the Earth is supported by four Elephant, which are supported by the cosmic tortoise and Adi-Shesha, and all of which, ultimately are supported by unmanifest powers of Vishnu himself.