2

I am clarifying my previous question again since without reading the details someone send it to duplicate.

4

There is little agreement on the birth year and details of shri Adishankaracharya.

I have undertaken 2 research efforts on this query. You can find them below -

Adhishankaracharya's Birth Year Controversy

With some research, you will easily discover that it is a very difficult task to arrive at the exact date and time of birth of Shri Adishankaracharya owing to limited and contradictory nature of information provided by various sources (the above link). In fact, it is only after several years of his departure that his birth place discovered to be Kalady. It will be fair to assume that no one can be reasonably certain about Acharya’s birth time unless they have concrete evidence or credible sources to rely on.

This research aims to create an understanding of his horoscope from pieces of information available today, spread across various sources. A primitive study of his horoscope will help find newer perspectives to understand his greatness.

Several Shankara Vijayams provide details about planetary positions at his time of birth (luckily, the authors do not significantly contradict each other at any point). The authors of these sources are reputed and honorable individuals of great character, apart from being scholars themselves. Lets look at them here:

  1. Madhaviya Sankara Vijayam, Translated by Swami Tapasyananda

लग्ने शुभे शुभयुते सुषुवे कुमारं श्रीपार्वतीव सुखिनी शुभवीक्षिते च । जाया सती शिवगुरोर्निजतुङगसंस्थे सूर्ये कुजे रविसुते च गुरौ च केन्द्रे ॥ (२.७२)

“The lagna being placed in a Shubha rasi, in conjunction with auspicious planets, the chaste wife of Shivaguru gave birth to a great son just like Shri Parvathi gave birth to Kumara (Shri Skanda), when Sun, Mars and Saturn occupied their positions of innate strength (Uccha, Mulatrikona or swakshetra) and Guru in Kendra.”

  1. Age of Sankara by T.S. Narayana Sastry

This magnificent work done is the fruit of some detailed research done by the author. In the book, Sastry mentions (on page 32) the names of 10 shankara vijayas and several other authentic sources (on page 33) such as Punyasloka manjari and Guruparampara records present in advaithic mutts, Jina Vijaya, Maddhva Vijaya and Mani manjari which provide insights on planetary positions during Shankaracharya’s birth. The author quotes the birth details of Shri Adishankara from Brihat Sankara Vijaya (not currently available in digital form) written by Chitsukhacharya (a person who claims to be a co-pupil in the same gurukula where Shri Shankara studied during his early) on Page 36 as below: “By the grace of Vrishadrinatha (the lord of vrishadri – vadakunatha swamy, trichur), in the all auspicious Nandana samvatsara of the year 2593 in Kali Yuga (corresponding to 5th century BCE), on a Sunday (Bhanu Vasara), when the sun was in the northern path (Uttharayana), on the 5th lunar day (Panchami Thithi) of the bright fortnight (Shukla Paksha),in the month of Vaishaka (Lunar month), in the asterism of Punarvasu and under the sign of Sagittarius in the zodiac (dhanur lagna), was born, in a miraculous manner, a wonderful male child from the scared womb of Aryamba, the dutiful wife of Shivaguru.”

  1. Notable Horoscopes by BV Raman

There is famous sloka quoted by eminent researchers such as BV Raman (in the footnotes of his book, page 30) about the birth day of Shankaracharya (which the mutts agree). Transliterating it here after correcting minor spelling mistakes:

शुक्लपक्षेषु पञ्चम्यां तिथ्यां भास्करवासरे । मध्याह्नेछोभिजिन्नाम मुहुर्ते शुभ वीक्षते ॥

“In the 5th lunar day of the fortnight, on Sunday, at the mid time of Abhijit muhurta, considered auspicious.” (Standalone, it’s an incomplete sentence. Must be a part of a larger paragraph)

BV Raman’s research also quotes some more details (on the same page) that confirm the position of Venus in Meena (exaltation) and Mercury in conjunction with Sun (from the works of Chitsukhacharya and Chidvilasa, whose digital form is not available).

At this juncture, one can wonder as to why can’t the horoscope indicated by BV Raman, be considered authentic and final. This is indeed a valid consideration owing to the scholarly astrologer he was. But the horoscope proposed by him loses its authenticity because BV Raman GREATLY relies on the records on Sringeri math (which states 44 BCE as the year of birth on page 31) for casting the horoscope. Now that Sringeri itself has moved its claim to 788 CE, our faith on Raman’s proposed horoscope unfortunately stands challenged, rendering his proposed horoscope in the realm of doubt. Now, if you are wondering as to how can you consider this blog to be authentic given that the matter in concern (year of birth) itself is hard to prove – my judgement of the horoscope heavily relies on Sanskrit works. I also place my faith on reputed Acharyas and vidwans who undertake the act of composing Shankara Vijayam as a service to the lord (from where I extract my data points).

Horoscope and Validation Basis the above details, what we can infer are as below:

  1. From Source 1, Surya must be placed in Mesha (Lunar Vishaka month and Sun in place of strength), Mars in Makara, Mesha or Vrushika AND Shani in Thula, Makara or Kumba. The Sanskrit bhashyam of Madhaviya Shankara vijaya refers this as the place of exaltation – needs validation.

  2. From Source 2, Chandra placed in Mithuna.

Sources 1, 2 & 3 are in agreement with the above judgement (w.r.t planetary placements of Surya and Chandra) since the Thithi is mentioned to be Panchami, giving about 48 – 60 degrees of difference between Surya and Chandra. Now since Chandra is placed in Punarvasu Nakshatra (81 – 93.33 degrees), there is a 9 degree possibility window making this an astrologically viable combination. The Shukla Paksha proves that Chandra is ahead of Surya in the zodiac belt (in agreement).

  1. From Source 3, Budha placed in Mesha (along with Surya) AND Shukra placed in Meena

  2. From source 1, Guru is placed in Kendra and Lagna is in conjunction with a shubha graha. Now, source 2 states that Lagna is Dhanur Rasi (Abhijit Muhurta occurs at mid-night too). Now, except Guru, we have only Rahu and Ketu who are natural and functional malefics (Ketu 12th Lord and Rahu 3rd Lord). The inference derived here is that Lagna and Guru are placed in Dhanur Rasi (Lagna owning to be one of the Kendra sthanas).But this needs some validation.

  3. Now, to conclude on the positions of Rahu and Ketu and validate other planetary positions, I am compelled to use source 2 which says the year of birth is 2593 years in kali (corresponding to 509 BC). We are currently in 5118, resulting in a rough difference of 2525. Now, a simple experiment to get an idea.

Let’s take planets revolution period (in days for accuracy), their current positions and simultaneously reverse calculate their positions 2525 years ago (with reasonable accuracy) and see its match against the slokas. This can be further validated in predictive sense to arrive at an accurate position.

enter image description here

** This is arrived by subtracting the MOD value from their current position. Reasonable exemptions (minimal) are taken into account since exact calculations is not viable. I agree that it can affect accuracy but I am convinced. Try it for yourself and let me know in case you find DRASTICALLY different results). Also Since traditionally the years start in April and we are just 2/3 months away from the start of the 5118th year, this can compensate for the decimal difference spread over 2500 years. So, my conclusion of the horoscope (by above method) is

enter image description here

The ultimate validation of the horoscope lies in its ability to correctly explain life events. No human is capable of undertaking an IN-DEPTH analysis of an incarnation’s horoscope. So, my humble attempt is to SUPERFICIALLY interpretation it (where I welcome criticism by scholars) against information we know for sure so as to substantiate the chart. Details are as follows:

  1. Extremely great and virtuous character – Hamsa Yoga (Gu L1 - H1). Exalted Venus in kendra with rasi drishti to lagna, Exalted L9 in H5 with Budha having drishti of L1 & L5 on H5. Shubha yoga (benefic in H1), Gajakesari, Amala Yoga (Benefic Ve in 10th from Moon), Parvata yoga (Benefic Gu,Ve, Ch in Kendras, 8th Vacant), Bhairi Yoga (12,1,2,7th occupied with 9th lord is strong), Kurma Yoga, Lakshmi Yoga

  2. Omniscience – L1& L4 in H1, Exalted planet in H4, Shukra drishti on L1 (Rasi drishti), L4 drishti on H4 (Rasi drishti), Chandra drishti on L4 (Rasi Drishti), Hamsa Yoga, Parvata yoga,

  3. Moksha at the end – 12th lord (Mars) is exalted in 2nd, its dispositor in mulatrikona, 12th Lord (Ketu ) exalted in 12th along with exaltation Rahu drishti on H12, L9 exalted in H5.

  4. Lots of verbal fights with ‘several opponents’ and Victory – Kuja exaltation in 2nd house equips one with great skill and is in Kendra to Budha. Rahu exalted in 6th (victory over lots of opponents). Nipuna Yoga (L9 exalted in H5 with L7). Shani Drishti on H6.

  5. Sanyasa – Guru + Kuja + Shani drishti on H5 having exalted Surya (L9) and Budha (L10), L7 eclipsed by Surya, Malefic in L2, Ve in Kona to Ketu, L8 in H7 helmed between Rahu and Ketu ( am not fully confident since the condition of multiple grahas in same rasi is absent. Need more research in this regard)

  6. Alpa Ayu - L8 in H7 helmed between Rahu and Ketu, malefic Kuja drishti on H8, 6th lord Rashi drishti on L8. Malefics in H2 & H12, L1 losing benevolence due to Kendradhipathi Dosha, Ashubha yoga (malefics in H2 and H12). While all this help reduce ayu, Exalted Ve in kendra, L9 exalted in L5 along with Bu as friend, Hamsa Yoga, strong Gu (L1) drsihti on L8, L8 placed in Kendra, Saturn with strength bestow unprecedented fame, so much that even today (after a minimum of thousand plus years), we talk about this work.

The Ayu for one who has taken Jeeva Samadhi is very difficult to attribute, similar to the tale of Ayu predictions done for Shri Yati Raghavendra (Deity at Mantralayam). The tale mentions that 3 different predictions were made, one around 100, second about 500 and third about 750. While the Samadhi of Shri Shankara is claimed to be present at Kedarnath (at Kanchi by few - controversy), no one saw him attaining his ‘death’.

All said and done, this horoscope needs more research to defend or deny its accuracy.

3

Following are the details available from Sringeri Sharda Peetha's official site, on the article Shankara Digvijaya – Part 1

Shankara was born to Aryamba and Shivaguru, a Nambudri Brahmana who belonged to the Vedic branch of Krishna Yajur Veda. Shankara’s birthplace was Kalady in Kerala, on the banks of the Poorna river. Kalady is situated a few miles from Tiru Shiva Perur (present-day Trichur), which contains the Shiva mound Vrischachala where Shivaguru and Aryamba prayed and were blessed with the divine child. **This event of the birth of Sri Shankara in 788 A.D that marked the beginning of the revival of the Vedic system is described thus in the Madhaviya Shankara Vijayam – ‘Just as the Divine Mother, Parvati begot Sri Subrahmanya, the virtuous Aryamba begot Sri Shankara on the auspicious Vaisaka sukla panchami (fifth day of the waxing moon during April-May) in the year 788 A.D, when the star attributed to Lord Shiva, Arudra was in ascendance with the Sun, Saturn, Jupiter, and Mars in exaltation.’ –

लग्नेशुभे शुभयुते सुषुवे कुमारं
श्री पार्वतीव सुखिनी शुभवीक्षिते च ।
जाया सती शिवगुरोः निजतुङ्ग संस्ते
सूर्येकुजे रविसुते च गुरौचकेन्द्रे ॥

You can read Madhaviya Shankara Digvijayam at here.
Quoting the text related to the mentioned verse:

71-82) At the birth of the baby the planetary position was as follows: The Lagna was fully aspecled by the benign planets like Guru Mars, Sun and Saturn were exalted and Guru was at the zenith. It was an easy delivery, as if Parvathi were giving birth to Skanda. At the sight of his son's face, Sivaguru was drowned in a sea of joy. Somehow controlling himself, he proceeded to bathe for performing the post-natal rituals, and bestowed much wealth as Dakshina on pious Brahmanas as part of those rites.

  • Thanks. 788ad can be ruled out because no such configuration happenned in the sky anywhere in and around that year. However the configuration itself is interesting, though Shukla panchami and Arudra are a very rare combination in Vishaka month. 2593 yudhistir saka is another date mentioned in above doc. However this saka is yet not clear to me. – Rama27 Nov 11 '17 at 17:20
  • In the book "The Age of Shankara by T. S. Narayana Sastry" the Nakshatra Punarvasu is mentioned instead of Arudra. Punarvasu is much more feasible combination technically with Shukla Panchami and Vaishaka month. – Rama27 Nov 12 '17 at 6:37
  • @Rama27 Well, the book I linked in the answer also discuss various confusions/opinions regarding dates of Adi Shankaracharya. – Paṇḍyā Nov 12 '17 at 6:56
  • 1
    The book you posted is a very good starting point. I am researching to clear the confusion. Arudra is Shiva. The clue lies in figuring out Yudhistir saka. – Rama27 Nov 12 '17 at 7:23

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .