4

Can a Hindu king or ruler suspend the dharma śāstras and other law books at difficult times e.g., during famine, floods, internal conflicts or when the state is actively engaged in a war?

If yes, can the king also impose a curfew on his citizens and suspend civil liberties?

5

According to Parashara Smriti (PS), during "ApatkAla" or during an emergency, following/maintaining Dharma must take a backseat. Preserving one's life, at that time, is the only priority. And, one should wait for the unrest to be over.

So, this is in other words the same as saying "One can abandon the Dharma ShAstras temporarily till the emergency is over".

enter image description here


Deshabhange pravAse vA bhyAdhishu vyasaneshvapi |
RanedevasvadehAdi paschAddharmam samAchAret ||


  1. During a civil commotion, or in exile, or when ill, or in misfortune, the first consideration is to preserve one's life ; practice of religion should at the time be postponed.

So, the king can very well use this injunction to issue such an order that abandon following the ShAstras till the unrest is over. But, I do not know of any such explicit verse where a king is specifically instructed to do so.

The above verse is PS 7.35. The next two verses are as follows:

  1. By any kind of conduct, soft or cruel, one should deliver himself from a distressed state ; the practice of religious rites ought to be left for a period when he is equal to the task.

enter image description here


ApatkAle tu nistirno sauchAchAram tu chintayet |
Suddhim samuddharet pashchAtswastho dharmam samacharet ||

  1. After the misfortune is over, one should think of purification and religious rites. Thereafter purity may be recovered by him. He ought to practice religion when his troubles are past.

Regarding your question about curfew, I have no idea.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .