1

I am trying to understand how the concept of the 7 heavens and 7 hells fits in with reincarnation in Hinduism.

It was my understanding that a person with Sattvic qualities would be reborn to Sattvic parents, and those with Tamasic qualities would be reborn in demonic wombs (according to the Gita) or as an animal.

However, then I was confused by reading of the concept of seven hells where people who have committed different kinds of sins would be punished and likewise 7 heavens.

How can both reincarnation and heaven and hell be true and how is heaven different to Moksha?

marked as duplicate by iammilind, Triyugi Narayan Mani, YDS, The Destroyer Jul 31 '18 at 16:46

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • One goes in Heaven or Hell only for a time period and has to be reincarnated on earth...but Moksha means uniting with the Supreme being and free from reincarnation...to understand better you can relate jail with hell from where a person returns once his punishment is over... – YDS Jul 31 '18 at 1:08
  • 1
    1) I think there are plenty of questions similar/same to this asked in this site, you may search there. 2) This is just Karmic effect, one may do bad karma whose fruit may be experienced either in hell or in next birth depending on that karma and similar for good Karma. 3) Being in heaven or hell is also like next birth, one gets new body there to experience pain/happiness. 4) Heaven is different from Moksha because attaining heaven is not eternal, heaven is subject to destruction in kalpas and mahapralayas, higher bliss than that of being in Swarga exists... etc... – Tejaswee Jul 31 '18 at 1:12
  • 2
    heavens (lokas) and hells are all temporal, they are not permanent. After going for a while a person's 'soul' (jiva) is reborn again. The vedas do not speak of hells. Hells is a concept that was developed later in the Puranas. What you think so you shall become. If you think of hells, then to hells you will go. If you think of heavens, to the heavens you shall go. If you think of God, then to God you shall go. Think of God; do not worry about heavens and hells... – Swami Vishwananda Jul 31 '18 at 4:37
2

Vedanta says that moral excellence is necessary for moksha or liberation. It is a simple fact that most people are morally imperfect. If you don’t accept the concept of reincarnation then you will have to face the question as to what happens to people who are morally imperfect. Do these people end up eternally in hell or do they cease to exist? If you choose one of these 2 unpleasant options then you can reject reincarnation. If you reject these 2 unpleasant options then you end up with the option of reincarnation which implies that imperfect people get chances to improve themselves and attain moksha. It is up to you to choose what you think is the most likely option.

How does the whole concept of reincarnation work?

We do not always reincarnate right after death. Nothing happens to the atman which is merely a witness. It is the subtle body that is affected by death.Check Gita 2.17-2.22 for the answer to your question. For example, Gita 2.22 says,

'Just as a man gives up old garments and puts on new ones, so the embodied self abandons decrepit bodies and assumes new ones.'

Gita 2.22

What happens immediately after death? The answer is given in Gita 15.8 which says,

‘When he gets a new body or abandons an old one, the Jiva, the lord of the body, moves, carrying them (the mind and the senses) with him, as the wind carries smells from their seats (in flowers and the like).’

Gita 15.8

What this means is that the physical body dies but the mind and the senses leave the physical body.Persons who have not attained moksha are part of the life-death-life.... cycle. They may also have to stay in heaven or hell for some time if they have done a particularly good thing or a heinous crime, respectively. After the merit of their particular good karma or the demerit of their particular bad karma is exhausted, they will again be born into the Earth plane. The process is linked to the concept of residual karma. This residual karma idea and what happens to evil-doers is explained in Brahma Sutra.

But of others (i.e. those who have not performed sacrifices etc.) the ascent is to the abode of Yama, and after having experienced (the results of their evil works) the descent (to the earth again takes place). On account of such a passage (for the evil-doer) being declared by the Sruti.

(Brahma Sutra Sankara Bhasya 3.1.13)

The Sruti passage referred to in the above shloka is:

The Hereafter never reveals itself to a person devoid of discrimination, heedless, and perplexed by the delusion of wealth. "This world alone exists," he thinks," and there is no other." Again and again he comes under my sway.

(Yama speaks in Katha Upanishad I.2.6)

It is clear that if you do bad deeds that you end up in Yama Loka. However, there are two perplexing questions here. Does the person who descends to earth from Yama loka return with any Karma (i.e. is the Karma of the evil-doer after serving his term in Yama loka zero?)? What decides that a person will after death be immediately reborn in earth or return to earth after serving a time in Yama loka? These two questions are actually linked. The answer to this question is given in Brahma Sutra:

On the exhaustion of (good) work (the soul) with residual Karma (descends to this earth), as is known from the Sruti amd Smriti, along the path (it) went by (from here) and differently too.

(Brahma Sutra Sankara Bhasya 3.1.8)

The above Sutra says that what is exhausted in heaven is only that specific Karma which gave the soul a birth in lower heaven, but on the exhaustion of this Karma the remaining Karma, good and bad, brings it back to earth. While this Sutra talks of heaven and good deed, it also applies to Yama Loka and bad deeds. Let me explain the idea by a concrete example. Let us suppose that a dead person has a list of 10 karmas with goodness values (1, -3, 4, 5, -100, 4, 3, 2, 5, 8) where the minus sign stands for evil deeds. What Brahma Sutra Sankara Bhasya 3.1.8 is saying is that this person will go to Yama Loka only for that extremely evil deed of goodness value -100. After he has exhausted the bad effect due to the -100 Karma, he can then go back to earth with the residual karma (1, -3, 4,5,4,3,2,5,8). The idea is that only extremely evil or good deeds (that can not be punished or rewarded in the Earth plane) lead a man to Yama loka or to lower heavens. All minor good and bad karmas are served on the earth plane.

Only the person who has attained moksha is free forever from the endless cycle of Samsara. The cycle of birth and death will only end after the attainment of moksha or liberation. The length of the process will depend on how quickly or slowly the person will attain moksha.

  • Does any of the scripture mention exactly what can be experienced only in heaven and not on earth? What can a Jiva experience in heaven which is not possible to experience on earth even as a king? – Chinmay Sarupria Jul 31 '18 at 17:17
  • I don't know if there is any scriptural mention. – Pradip Gangopadhyay Aug 1 '18 at 11:27

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .