1

In the book 'Sri Sarada Devi - Holy Mother' there are references in quite a few places of the Holy Mother preparing betel rolls for The Master, also we know that Sri Ramakrishna Paramhansa died of throat cancer (as the book states), so just curious to know whether the cause of his death was chewing betel rolls having tobacco etc that lead to throat cancer?

Second part of the question, did Sri. Ramakrishna Paramhansa died in samadhi like his disciple Swami Vivekananda and was he aware of his death time just like Vivekanada was??

  • Do you know that throat cancer is not caused by any such cause? – user17294 May 2 '19 at 15:22
  • I beg to differ for my grand mother died for the same reason and yes, she used to chew tobacco. @commonman – Just_Do_It May 2 '19 at 15:23
  • That can cause oral cancer and not throat cancer! And anyway, this was not possible to detect the cause at that time.And I do not think it has anything to do with Hinduism in particular! – user17294 May 2 '19 at 15:25
  • Some biographies say He was.But I do not want to quote them here. – user17294 May 2 '19 at 15:54
  • 2
    please limit questions to one question at a time. see forum rules. the causes of Ramakrishna's cancer is a matter of medical (i.e., scientific) speculation, not a question about the Hindu religion. – Swami Vishwananda May 3 '19 at 11:35
2

A Short Life of Sri Ramakrishna by Swami Tejasananda (published by Advaita Asrama) states that he used to consume large amounts of ice during the summer period of 1885 which led to a badly affected throat and eventually he was diagnosed with throat cancer shortly thereafter.

So, if we are to link the disease to any direct cause then that cause will be ice consumption and not that of betel leaves/nuts.

However, there is another story according to which Sri Ramakrishna used to allow all sorts of people touching him when they came for his visit. And, among which a lot of people would be mortal sinners. Their sins transmitted and assumed the form of a deadly disease.

The Mother Goddess once showed to Ramakrishna scars in his throat and explained how those came. This was much before he actually was affected with throat cancer.

During the sultry months of the year 1885 the Master suffered a great deal from the terrible heat, which was alleviated by the taking of ice the devotees brought to him daily.

But this frequent use of ice produced a pain in the throat which was at first so trifling as to pass unnoticed. But in a month it became so aggravated that the disciples grew alarmed and called in a specialist in diseases of the throat. Notwithstanding the prescription of various remedies, his condition did not show any sign of improvement. On days of the full and the new moon, the pain became more acute; it was impossible for him to eat solid food. The doctors diagnosed the disease as ‘Clergyman’s sore throat’. The Master carried out the doctors’ injunctions faithfully, except on two points, namely checking the divine ecstasies and giving rest to the vocal organs.

And, it was in June 1885 when he was diagnosed with throat cancer as mentioned in the book "A Short Life of the Holy Mother".

In June 1885, Sri Ramakrishna developed cancer of the throat, and this necessitated his removal in October to Shyampukur in Calcutta for treatment. The devotees arranged for everything regarding medical care, nursing, and so on.


Second part of the question, did Sri. Ramakrishna Paramhansa died in samadhi like his disciple Swami Vivekananda and was he aware of his death time just like Vivekanada was??

It is mentioned in the same biography I have quoted from that he entered Mahasamadhi. The full details are as follows:

At last the eventful day arrived—a day of intense grief for the devotees. It was Sunday, August 15, 1886, the last day of Shravana. The Master’s suffering was at its highest. The devotees wept in grief. They stood by the bed-side of the Master. In the evening he suddenly fell into Samadhi. The body became stiff. There was something about this Samadhi which struck Shashi as unusual, and he began to weep.

After midnight Sri Ramakrishna regained consciousness. The Master in a clear voice uttered thrice the name of Kali and gently lay down. Suddenly at two minutes past one, a thrill passed through the Master’s body, making the hair stand on end. The eyes became fixed on the tip of the nose and the face was lit up with a smile. The Master entered into Mahasamadhi. Thus in the early hours of Monday, the 16th of August 1886, Sri Ramakrishna departed from the world, leaving behind a host of grief-stricken devotees and admirers.

| improve this answer | |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .