Can someone explain this with examples

As far as i understand, a person responds to a situation as per their guna.

But are situations too tailored to the match a person's guna?

My question is not about a person’s response to a situation according to guna. It is about how guna affects a the way a predestined event ie.. the way Karma plays out in a person’s life.

Suppose a person, AAA, has to recover something from another, BBB, and it could not be done in that very lifetime. Then, in another lifetime, AAA can recover the dues from BBB by

1) stealing/ pickpocket / cheating BBB. Which means AAA is in tamasic mode. Or

2) being born as a child to BBB. Which means AAA is in satvik mode Or

3) be an inefficient employee to BBB. Which means AAA is in Rajasic mode.

4) be in some position to take gifts from BBB

5) or some other mode of recovery, like inheriting in a long winded manner because direct heirs have died.

So, will the kind of rebirth of AAA have, to effect the recovery, be as per AAA's guna?

Or does something else also affect the way a person is reborn?

i hope i am clear now.

Regards Geetha

  • Yes, working for livelihood is Satvik, Eating-Entertainment is Rajsik, Sleeping is Tamsik and meditation-scripture studying is Nirguna. Childhood is Tamsik, Adulthood is Rajsik and Old age is Satvika, Aatma is Nirguna. hinduism.stackexchange.com/a/35195/16530 – user16530 Sep 19 '19 at 14:40
  • Sorry what's your question exactly? Are you asking how the 3 gunas affect a person's behavior? – Ikshvaku Sep 19 '19 at 17:07
  • @ Ikshvaku & @ Manu Kumar - I have edited my question with a suitable example – Sri Janani Sep 19 '19 at 20:29

Apologies. I think the second sentence needs to be revisited. Person doesn't respond as per Gunas. Gunas are our genetic predisposition, but they don't determine actions/pre destined events.

What you are talking about is cause and effect. Effects of the actions in a given birth are felt in subsequent birth(s). Point is to still follow path of Dharma taking into account your gunas

  • “The Three Stonecutters”, a story well known in management circles, courtesy Peter Drucker (Please look it up in the net) illustrates how behaviour and the three Gunas are connected. But a fourth type of response possible, by a person who has transcended Gunas, is not a part of the original story. Such a person will respond by saying that it is a privilege bestowed on me by God, that he has got this opportunity to contribute towards the building of the cathedral. This kind of person is the one who will work with most dedication, as the person considers the work an offering to God. – Sri Janani Sep 24 '19 at 17:03
  • To Carmen - due to lack of space in the commenting section, I am continuing here in the second comment. The person who has transcended the Gunas develops a “Witness” standpoint of looking at life and an attitude of equanimity and composure, undisturbed by circumstances of life, so essential for spiritual development. – Sri Janani Sep 25 '19 at 4:24
  • 1
    If and only if you commence and stick through the "sanyaasi" path to attain moksha, and that is when you have overcome gunas. Doing yogs (be it "spreading the word", "building cathedrals") etc also enable spiritual development. And these activities are influenced (not controlled or determined) by gunas. Hope it is clear. Force fitting teachings of management or other religions will just lead to confusion – Carmen sandiego Sep 27 '19 at 4:56

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .