3

I thought 'tarka shastra' was the search text I was looking for, but the books I found were rather modern writer's literary text.

What I was looking for the science written by the rishis, I just found a few hints in Prabhupada's book of the Bhagavad Gita, that quoted techniques like the 'jalpa' . I was searching for the scriptic/Vedic/profound texts i.e. written by the sages that talked about the art and science to converse/debate. If there are any, please mention them .

0
2

Argumentation was established by the Nyaya school. In his book, A Critical Survey of Indian Philosophy (https://archive.org/details/IndianPhilosophyACriticalSurvey), the author writes at the beginning of his chapter on the Nyaya:

The sage Gotama is the founder of the Nyaya School. He is also known as Gautama and as Aksapada. Nyaya means argumentation and suggests that the system is predominately intellectual, analytic, logical and epistemological. It is called Tarkashastra or the science of reasoning; Pramanashastra or the science of logic and epistemology; Hetusvidya or the science of causes; Vadavidya or the science of debate; and Anviksiki or the science of critical study.

Gotama's Nyaya-sutra was commented upon by Vatsyayana in his Nyaya-Bhasya. On this Uddyotakara wrote his Varika which was commented upon by Vachaspati in his Tatparya-tika. Udayana's Nyaya-kusumanjali and Jayanta's Nyaya-manjari are the other important works of this school. THe Navya-nyaya or the modern school of Indian logic begins with the epoch-making Tattva-chintamani of Gangesha. Vasudeva, Raghynatha, Mathuranatha, Jagadsiha and Gadadhara are the eminent logicians of this school.

A reading of the chapter is a good introduction to the Nyaya school. There is also a translation by Swami Madhavananda of the Bhasa Pariccheda with Siddhanta Muktavali written by Visvanatha-Nyaya-Pancanana Bhattacarya in the 1700s AD which is a study on the Navya-nyaya.

As a side note, in most debates one person takes the Siddhanta, conclusions to be established. The other takes the Purvapaksha, objections raised.

1

It seems like one of the ancient texts on the art of debate is from Ayurveda. Please check Sushruta Samhita and Charaka Samhita.

According to Wikipedia

... Pariksa, deals with the standard of examination. These standards are aptopadesa (reliable assertion) pratyaksa (perception), anumana (inference), yukti (reasoning)....

Personally, this seems to be more elaborate than just pointers. Hope this helps.

2
  • it seems a bit general though. Because I wanted texts that deal with reasoning only though
    – juztcode
    Oct 27 '20 at 9:26
  • 2
    I see. If I find anything more along these lines, I will update my answer. Thanks! Oct 27 '20 at 16:01

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .