7

Hinduism is based on principle of dharma (unlike Buddhism and Jainism which are based on principle of Karma).

And all varnas have different duties(dharma) to discharge.

So, what is the dharma prescribed for outcastes who don't come under the four varnas .

14
  • 3
    "Varna is based on birth" - what?? Seems you have not read any Hindu scriptures except semi-sacred smritis. And you are making unscientific, political statement. – R. Kaushik Jun 13 at 19:33
  • 4
    If Varna was not based on birth ,then why did Dronacharya refuse to give education to Karna but gave the education to all 100 Kauravs and 5 Pandavs ? – river Jun 13 at 19:34
  • 3
    Please stop spreading TOTAL MISINFORMATION - Nowhere is caste angle mentioned in Sanskrit text!!! The reason was personal. MBH was written by a mixed-caste man with a mixed-caste mother. Yadu was also a suta by caste and he became King. Balarama & Krishna were descendants of Yadu. There are soooo many examples of Varna migration in MBH. Lord Shiva himself says you can change it in MBH. Please read Hindu scriptures before ever making such statements. Only smritis say Varna is birth-based/unchanging. – R. Kaushik Jun 13 at 19:54
  • 4
    @R.Kaushik It is laughable to think that varna can be "changed" . Can a lion become a dog ? No , then how can Varna be changed ? And Varna is by birth , just like a lion will always produce a lion and a dog will always give birth to a dog. It is quite simple .because of political propaganda people have started to think that varna is not based on birth and can be changed. Even the statement is contradictory " If Varna is not based on birth " . Then why migration , then why keep the concept of varna at all. If you don't believe in Varna , you should go to Buddhism or Jainism – river Jun 13 at 20:28
  • 4
    @R.Kaushik I am serious and want to know about what duties are prescribed for untouchable caste. BTW i belong to general category . there are many castes which belong in general category are originally untouchable or shudras. – river Jun 13 at 20:45
7

PV Kane in his History of Dharma Sastras Vol 2 Part 1 page 89 writes

The theory of the early smṛtis was that there were only four varṇas and there was no fifth varṇa. Vide Manu X.4 and Anuśāsana-parva 47.18.890. When in modern times the so-called untouchables are referred to as the pañcamas that is something against the smṛti tradition. Panini II 4.10 and Patañjali say that a Samāhāra dvandva compound can be formed from several subdivisions of śūdras that are not niravasita e.g. we can have the compound ‘taksāyaskāram’ meaning carpenters and blacksmiths, but not 'caṇḍāla-mṛtapam’ because caṇḍālas and mṛtapas are niravasita Śūdras (and so the compound will be 'caṇḍālamṛtapāḥ). Therefore it follows that Panini and Patañjali included caṇḍalas and mṛtapas among śūdras. When Angiras (note 171 above) includes kṣatr, suta, vaidehika, magadha and ayogava (that are pratiloma castes) among antyavasayins along with caṇḍāla and śvapaca, he makes it clear that he regarded caṇḍalas as included among śūdras, for Manu X.41 declares that all pratiloma castes are similar to śūdras in their dharma and because the śāntiparva 297.2S 393 expressly says that the vaidehika is called Śūdra by learned dvijas.

Medhatithi says on Manu 10.41

Those sons however who are born of ‘violation’—i.e., of a mixture of the castes—‘are of the nature of Śūdras,’—i.e., having the character of the Śūdra, they are entitled to the rights and duties of that caste.

This implies that Chandalas and all other Pratilomas can do the works of Sudras. In Mahabharata Anushasana Parva 48, Jobs are allocated based on Varna of their parents which is presented in the table as follows -

enter image description here

Finally, Bhishma says

The duties have been laid down in the scriptures for only the four principal orders. As regards the others the scriptures are entirely silent. Among all the orders, the members of those castes that have no duties assigned to them by the scriptures, need have no fears as to what they do (to earn their livelihood). Having recourse to spots where four roads meet, or crematoria, or hills and mountains, or forests and trees, they build their habitations there. They may be seen to live in this way, adorning their persons with ornaments and employed in the task of manufacturing diverse kinds of domestic and other utensils. Without doubt, by assisting kine and Brahmanas, and practising the virtues of abstention from cruelty, compassion, truthfulness of speech, and forgiveness, and, if need be, by preserving others by laying down their very lives, persons of the mixed castes may achieve success. (Anushasana Parva 48 : 4 )

2
  • 1
    This is a very important "go-to table" for easy recollection. NICE – peace Jun 14 at 6:13
  • 1
    Thanks for the answer. – river Jun 14 at 8:37
4

Manu Smrti - Ch 10

But the dwellings of ‘Fierce’ Untouchables (Candalas) and ‘Dog-cookers’ (Svapacas) should be outside the village; they must use discarded bowls, and dogs and donkeys should be their wealth. (10.51)

Their clothing should be the clothes of the dead, and their food should be in broken dishes; their ornaments should be made of black iron, and they should wander constantly. (10.52)

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .