31

Given that the great Abhimanyu was an expert at Chakra-Vyuha (a.k.a Padma-Vyuha), why couldn’t he manage to come out of it?

Krishna was also an expert in Chakra-Vyuha at that time, so why didn't he rescue Abhimanyu?

  • 1
    Take a look at this Quora answer as well, beautifully done. – Aditya Somani Jul 10 '14 at 1:55
  • I think Krishna did not save Abhimanyu to save Arjuna from Chakravyuh.. Krishna knew that if they want to win battle, Arjuna has to stay on ground in front of Karna. 1. If arjuna took part in chakravyuh, he would have died in it. So krishna sent Abhimanyu. 2. Krishna sent Bhim's son in battle to use a powerful tool on it by Karna which can be used once only . So Karna can not use it in front of Arjuna afterwards. – user2712 Mar 30 '15 at 18:19
  • When Lord Vishnu came to earth to put down adharma all God's sent their ammsa..part of their strength to help Lord Vishnu to fulfil his duty of protecting Dharma. In that process Moon who loved his son immensely hesitated to send his son to earth.when all devas forced him to send he sent his son to earth to be born to Arjuna and shall stay for short period of 16years and will come to his original place.as such Chandr s son was born as Abhimanyu and stayed for 16 years and died in the battle field and went back to his original place.this is in original Sanskrit Mahabharata. Dsastry. – user5547 May 5 '16 at 14:57
37
+50

Vyuha generally means an arrangement. So chakra vyuha means the arrangement of soldiers in the form of a wheel. This was an old warfare technique like garuda vyuha, makara vyuh, mandala vyuh etc. Chakra vyuh being hard to penetrate Drona chose it on the thirteenth day of war when Abhimanyu got killed.

Chakra Vyuha Explanation

Abhimanyu failed to break it because he had not learnt how to break it. In fact, he had not learnt the technique to enter into it in the traditional way. While he was in his mother's womb Arjuna used to talk about war strategies to Subhadra and from that only he had learned the technique. However, while talking about how to breakout of a chakra vyuha Subhadra got asleep and Abhimanyu couldn't listen the technique. So he only knew how to break into a chakra vyuha, but not how to break out of it in case of any danger.


Why didn't Shri Krishna rescue Abhimanyu?

Yes, it is true that apart from Abhimanyu, two other people on the Pandav side who knew about chakra vyuha strategy were Shri Krishna and Arjuna. But as per their strategy, before forming the chakra vyuha, Susarman of the Kauravas challenged Arjuna for fighting and lured him away along with his chariot driver Shri Krishna to the southern part of the battle field. So both Arjuna and Krishna were unaware about what was going on with Abhimanyu. Had they been present there, then Arjuna would have certainly done something if not Shri Krishna, as He had given his word to not use weapons in the battle.

Reference: MB - 7.31,33

  • About your words after image, Abhimanyu does know how to break and enter into Chakravyooha, but don't know how to come out of it. And its Krishna who was explaining Chakravyuha Bhedana to Subhadra. He explained how to break it and enter, after that Krishna saw Subhadra was sleeping, so he stopped explaining further, which is coming out of Chakravyooha safely. – Bharadwaj Jul 11 '14 at 13:58
  • @Bharadwaj yeah, may be. But in Mahabharat[7.34.19] Abhimanyu says he had learnt about the piercing technique from his father (Arjuna). उपदिष्टॊ हि मे पित्रा यॊगॊ ऽनीकस्य भेदने – Be Happy Jul 17 '14 at 5:45
  • I referred Bhagavatam and Krishnavatara which says Krishna was taking pregnant Subhadra to his home in a chariot, on the way just to entertain her, he was explaining all tricks of Yuddha Bhoomi along with Chakravyooha rachana and how to penetrate the forces. – Bharadwaj Jul 17 '14 at 5:54
  • @Bharadwaj yeah,ok. That's why I said may be. Because we know these stories can have many variations in various puranas and scriptures. So no point in trying to find out who taught whom what. The war is already over and we ain't got those divine visions like Sanjay :) – Be Happy Jul 17 '14 at 6:07
  • May be, depends on how they analyze it :) – Bharadwaj Jul 17 '14 at 6:21
9

Why didn't Abhimanyu break out of Chakravyuh

As the story goes in Mahabharata, in their bed time Arjun was narrating a very ingenious Yyuha to his wife Subhadra. Subhadra was at that time expecting and she had Abhimanyu in her womb.

Subhadra was all vigilant during the first part of the narration which involved entering the Vyuha, but during the latter part i.e. exiting she felt sleepy and couldn't pay proper attention to it. So, Abhimanyu who was in her womb couldn't listen to the second part.

Mahabharata: Abhimanyu and Chakra-vyuha has a somewhat alternate story,

When Abhimanyu was in his mother's womb, Sri Krishna used to take Subhadra on excursions. To humour her, Krishna used to relate many of his adventures to the pregnant Subhadra. On one such excursion Krishna was narrating his experience with the technique of Chakra-vyuha and how step-by-step the various circles could be penetrated. Chakra-vyuha was a military formation which was an effective form of defence. The army would be arranged in the form of a circular grid and would then challenge the enemy to break that grid. Nonetheless, it seems that Subhadra did not find this topic interesting and she soon fell asleep. However, someone else was interested in Sri Krishna's narration - the yet to be born Abhimanyu.

While Subhadra dozed off, Abhimanyu continued to carefully follow Sri Krishna's narrative of the Chakra-vyuha. But, after talking for some time and not receiving any response from Subhadra, Sri Krishna realised that she was savouring a sweet nap. Sri Krishna, who had at that time come up to the seventh step of the Chakra-vyuha, gave up his narration and returned with Subhadra to the palace.

Why didn't Krishna help Abhimanyu out of Chakravyuha

As per the promise given to Pandavas and Kauravas about usage and distribution of his resources, he wasn't supposed to participate in the Mahabharata war, rather he was only supposed to be an advisor. Krishna with his power could have rescued Abhmanyu easily, but his promise prevented him to do so..

Sri Krishna's Kurushetra Lila explains this strory beautifully,

Sri Krishna was lying down, resting, when Duryodhana and Arjuna arrived. Duryodhana entered first, and sat near the head of Sri Krishna. He grabbed a chair and reclined. Arjuna did not sit on a chair. He stood with folded hands at the feet of Sri Krishna. After a while, Sri Krishna opened his eyes, and first, naturally, he could see only what was near his feet, not his head.

“Arjuna, how come you are here at this moment?” said Sri Krishna.

“No sir! I have come first,” said Duryodhana from behind.

“Oh! You have also come,” said Krishna.

Sri Krishna said, “You have come first, but I saw Arjuna first. Also, he is younger, you are the elder. Don’t you think it is proper for me to speak to the younger one first, especially as I saw him first?”

Then turning to Arjuna, Sri Krishna asked, “What made you come here?”

Arjuna replied, “Great Master, you know what is going to happen. War has become inevitable. We all want your help.”

Sri Krishna said, “What can I give you? I have two things. I have a large army called Narayani Sena; if you want it, you can take it. Otherwise I am here, but unarmed, doing nothing. I will merely sit and discuss with you. I will not take part in the war. If you want such a man as I am, take me. Or if you think this is not going to be of any utility to you, take the large army which will help you, as it is almost invincible.”

“I want you only, Master,” replied Arjuna.

Immediately Duryodhana retorted, “I want the army.”

“Take it,” said Sri Krishna.

Duryodhana left the place hurriedly, and declared to the Kuru family that he had already won victory in the war, that his victory was certain because of the invincible forces that he had received from Sri Krishna.

When Duryodhana left the place, Sri Krishna accosted Arjuna and said, “What a foolish person you are! Why did you not ask for the army? What good is it if I sit idle without doing anything for you? Why have you made this wrong choice? The other man took the good forces, and you are asking for me, who is as good as nothing.”

Arjuna replied, “Thou art all for me, great Master. I know you very well. Don’t try to deceive me by this query as to why I have chosen you.”

“Oh! You want to vie with me. Okay, all right. Do that,” said Krishna.

Then they both left.

  • 3
    It is said that Shri Krishna didn't explain the coming out of the chakravyuha on purpose even knowing that though Subhadra is asleep, the child (Abhimanyu) is listening. because Shri Krishna had curse from Kamsa (his uncle) that He will die in the hands of one of his nephews as he had. – Mr_Green Jun 28 '14 at 8:56
  • 1
    but Krsna didn't die in the hands of any of his nephews! – Vineet Menon Jun 28 '14 at 13:41
  • Yes, AFAIK, somehow all the nephews were dead in the night of 18th (last) day of Mahabharatha battle. Awhwatthama kills the sons of pandavas thinking they are pandavas themselves. I might be wrong but I heard that there is strategy of Shri Krishna behind it (makes Ashwatthama thinks them as pandavas with magic) to break the curse. – Mr_Green Jun 28 '14 at 13:55
  • Agree with @Mr_Green's first post. Krishna was having curse of killing his Mama kans. – The Dictator Jul 9 '14 at 5:00
2

Abhimanyu’s untimely death is attributed to his enmity with Lord Krishna in his previous birth. Abhimanyu in his previous birth was known as Abhikasura a demon. He was a friend of King Kans who left no stone unturned to kill his nephew Krishna. After Krishna killed Kans, Abhikasura vowed to take revenge on the former. Krishna, sensing the moves of the demon, wove a magic around Abhikasura, transformed him into an insect and captured him in a box. When Krishna’s sister Subhadra, after her wedding with Arjuna, accidentally opened the box, the insect got into her womb. Abhikasura was then born as Abhimanyu. Krishna knew this and he rather sadly, prepared the ground for the death of his nephew and finally got him entrapped in Padmavyuha. When Arjuna was mourning the death of his son and squarely blamed Krishna for it, it was then Krishna explained Abhikasura’s reincarnation as Abhimanyu and the necessity for him, as the Supreme Power, to incinerate the evil force.

  • 2
    Welcome To Hinduism SE! You Should Cite Sources. – SwiftPushkar Sep 1 '16 at 9:13

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .