2

Here's the 32nd verse, from chapter 9 of Shrimat Bhagavat gita.

मां हि पार्थ व्यपाश्रित्य येऽपि स्यु: पापयोनय: | स्त्रियो वैश्यास्तथा शूद्रास्तेऽपि यान्ति परां गतिम् || 9.32

TRANSLATION (Bhagavat Gita As it is)
O son of Prtha, those who take shelter in Me, though they be of lower birth-women, vaisyas [merchants], as well as sudras [workers]-can approach the supreme destination. 9.32


Now this verse has been a source of controversy as it seems, in some translations and interpretations, to say that souls are born as women because of their sins. But keeping that controversy aside for a moment and let's continue with the interpretation objectively.

This is following extract from Mahabharata Tatparya Nirnaya, translated by Nagesh D Sonde

enter image description here

The acts of merits and demerits of people being according to each one's attributes, the stage of a man of Wisdom and others are also normal according to their attributes and so is their deliverance. A male is born again as a female because of desires or some demerit. A female is never born as a male because of attributes but they reside within the male body alongside the male form in a spiritual female form. These spiritual female forms are unlimitedly superior to those who have taken female forms due to the demerit of desires. All Jivas attain the body of skin and flesh according to their attributes. In liberation, even after experiencing the effects of prior karmas, each one lives according to their true attribute, even the statement merits even for those born in evil-wombs can be accepted, because of the declaration in Bhavishya Purana.


Here it seems to say male souls are born as females because of their sins. But female souls are not born as men as result of their merits. Instead they will inhabit a male body in spritual female form...?

What exactly does this all mean?

According to Dviata, jeevatma or soul has its guna and swabhava unchanged.

1. Is gender an unchangeable attribute of the soul? Are there male souls and female souls which are eternally that??

2. Only male souls are born as women, but women souls are never born as men? So all men now can be sure that they are a male soul, but women can be either a male soul or female soul?

3. Also when a woman soul, due to her merits, inhabits a man body alongside another male soul? So are there two souls in one body. So can some men have two souls, one male soul and one spiritual female soul? If so does the female soul has any agency and decision making capacity or all the decision is made by the male soul and female soul simply sits by and experiences life?

1
1
+50

Ans 1: Yes Female and Male nature cannot be changed as its attaced to jiva swaroopa according to Sriman Madvacharya. Not to Linga , Aniruddha or Sukshma sharira. So According Sriman Madvacharya Females are eligible for moksha, if they perform respective sadhana. Females need not be born male to attain moksha.

Ans 2. Yes you are right female soul can never be born in male body but male souls can be born in female body. So all men can be sure that their soul is male, but women cannot be sure as their soul can be either male or female.

Ans 3.Yes female soul can be in male body, but male is the primary doer and enjoyer(kartha abd bhokta) of the body, whereas female soul cohabits the body as only enjoyer(bhokta). But the cohabiting bhokta soul can also make some small decisions based on karma, desire of jiva and will of God.
For example when Puthana tried to feed Sri krishna, it was Urvashi's desire that was fulfilled. But the other desire of mixing poison is made by other Rakshasa jeeva which is inside Puthana. But not all desire are made by bhokta jeeva, only the main jeeva makes most of the choices.

11
  • You are simply not understandimg my seconf question Jul 20 at 9:41
  • Men can be sure of their soul's gender, but women can't be sure. Yes or no??? Jul 20 at 9:42
  • Your second answer complete negates the third answer. female souls cannot be born in male body. Please refer to the bhashya. Jul 20 at 9:43
  • I said male body with female soul and also male soul which is submissive
    – Prasanna R
    Jul 20 at 10:24
  • 1
    Yes you are right female soul can never be born male but can co habit in male body but they are submissive may be the eunuch case will delete that is still question for me.the above is stated by .advacharya and raghavendra theertha also
    – Prasanna R
    Jul 20 at 11:34

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .